Justice Anthony Besanko’s ruling in a landmark defamation trial has exposed startling revelations regarding Ben Roberts-Smith, Australia’s highly decorated soldier. The judge concluded that Roberts-Smith had engaged in misconduct, including lying and threatening witnesses, and held him accountable for the murder of four Afghans. This judgment marks a significant moment in Australian history.
Key Findings and Trial Overview:
The 606-page judgment, handed down in the Federal Court of Australia after a 10-week trial, detailed Roberts-Smith’s alleged misdeeds. The soldier had filed a defamation suit against Nine newspapers, challenging articles that accused him of committing war crimes during his service in Afghanistan.
Lies and Threats:
Justice Besanko established that Roberts-Smith had lied about various incidents, notably the alleged murder of a handcuffed Afghan prisoner. Moreover, the judge found evidence of Roberts-Smith intimidating witnesses through text messages and emails, employing threats to silence them and protect his reputation.
Consequences and Reactions:
The judge’s findings carry significant consequences for Roberts-Smith’s future. Facing ongoing criminal investigations, he also had his meritorious unit citation revoked by the Australian Defence Force. The ruling has garnered mixed reactions, with praise for the judge’s thoroughness and criticism from those who believe the judgment fell short.
Unveiling the Dark Side:
Beyond individual implications, the trial has shed light on Australia’s involvement in the War in Afghanistan and raised profound questions about the conduct of its special forces. The judge’s findings expose a troubling chapter in the nation’s history, demanding a broader examination of its military actions.
Conclusion:
The landmark defamation trial’s verdict against Ben Roberts-Smith has reverberated through Australia’s military and legal landscape. The judge’s findings of lies, witness threats, and complicity in the murder of Afghan individuals have dealt a significant blow to Roberts-Smith’s reputation and potential legal standing. The trial also forces the nation to confront uncomfortable truths about its involvement in the War in Afghanistan.
